An Irrational and Obscene Hatred
By WILLIAM SHAWCROSS
07/06/2010
Israel is a cartoon villain, beyond sympathy, beyond
even redemption. What is shocking – and frightening
– is that the narrative the world accepts is always that
of Israel as the evildoer.
‘Shut up. Go back to Auschwitz.” That was the
response from the “peace flotilla” when Israel broadcast
a radio message warning the Turkish flotilla that it was about to enter
an area under naval blockade. I
n another response, someone on board the “humanitarian aid convoy”
replied: “We’re helping the Arabs go
against the US. Don’t forget 9/11, guys.” After these
exchanges, IDF commandos landed on the ships.
On the Mavi Marmara they were attacked by pro-Palestinian activists
wielding iron bars.
Turkish papers have now published photographs of soldiers bleeding badly as
they are assaulted by thugs.
Eventually the commandos shot back in self-defense and nine activists were
killed. It was a disaster for Israel
and a triumph for those who hate Israel, Jews and the West. Bulent
Yildirim, head of the Turkish Islamist
organization IHH, which organized the flotilla, exulted in a speech to
an audience he called “people of paradise.”
“Last night, everything in the world has changed, and everything is
progressing toward Islam,” he said.
THAT IS the reality today. Consider these words from Sheikh Hussein bin Mahmud,
a pseudonymous but
apparently popular commentator in the global jihadist community:
“Everyone who has had contact with the
Jews and lived alongside them, in the East and in the West, has spurned
them, loathed them and detested
them, to the point where Hitler said, ‘I could kill all the Jews in
the world, but I left a few alive so that the entire
world will know why I killed the Jews.’”
Such raw hatred of Jews, let alone Israel, is commonplace in the Middle East,
even without an excuse such
as last week’s deadly incident. The “peace flotilla” was no such
thing. It had some peaceful people aboard,
but its organizer, IHH, is a part of the Muslim Brotherhood, an openly
terrorist organization pledged to the
destruction of Israel and the triumph of Shari’a law everywhere.
Scores of the “peace passengers” were
Islamic militants pledged to kill Jews and secure martyrdom for
themselves. Hence the confrontation with the
Israeli commandos and the tragedy of the deaths on board.
That was not enough for Sheikh Hussein. He declared that the Turks should
“kill every Jew in Turkey.”
Moreover, “Gaza does not want ‘freedom ships’ bearing blonde women
with Muslim, Christian, Jewish
and atheist men; it wants a naval fleet and a land army bearing black
Islamic banners... Gaza will not agree to a
cease-fire with the Jews. On the contrary, it is thirsty to drink the
blood of the sons of apes and pigs, and it is
hungry and longs to devour the body parts of these cowards.”
Western critics of Israel often say that they are not anti-Semitic, merely
anti-Zionist. No such distinction
occurs to commentators such as Sheikh Hussein – Jews, Israelis, they
are all “the sons of apes and pigs.”
It is not surprising that such racist loathing creates a siege mentality in
Israel. Worse is the fact that Israelis
know it’s not just “the black Islamic banners” with which they
have to contend, but also the irrational hatred of
much of the rest of the world
The realities of Gaza, Israel and the West Bank – where, with Israel’s
assistance, the Palestinian economy is
booming – are deemed irrelevant to the conventional narrative. Israel
is a cartoon villain, beyond sympathy,
beyond even redemption. What is deeply shocking – and frightening –
is that the narrative the world accepts is
always that of Israel the evildoer.
It was true with the so-called Jenin massacre allegedly committed by the
Israelis in 2002. There was no such
massacre. It was a lie that was widely and uncritically propagated by
the UN, Amnesty International,
Human Rights Watch and the BBC. It is true today. The hatred that Israel
arouses is absurd, even obscene.
One senior military source was quoted last week as saying it did not
matter what his country did; however
carefully it responded to such events as the “peace flotilla,” it
would always be condemned in the UN, on the
BBC and almost everywhere else.
The bien pensants of the Western world are never prepared to give Israel the
benefit of any doubt.
The UN has become more of a lynch mob than a constructive debating
chamber. Israel’s right to defend
itself is ignored. So is the fact that Iran has threatened to obliterate
it, and that the Hamas rulers of Gaza are
Iranian agents also pledged to its destruction.
LAST WEEK, the UN, as always, jumped instantly to the conclusions most
damaging to Israel.
The UN Human Rights Council, of which Iran is a member, instantly
denounced Israel for its
“attacks on the flotilla of ships carrying humanitarian assistance.”
Similarly, the Israeli ambassador to the EU was harangued and abused in the
European Parliament’s
Foreign Affairs Committee. No one was interested in his explanation, and
when he showed images of IDF
soldiers being beaten with iron bars on the Mavi Marmara, MEPs asserted
the film was faked propaganda.
The only person to defend Israel at all was Charles Tannock, the
Conservative MEP. (
Unlike the Israeli ambassador, the Iranian ambassador was treated with
courtesy.)
Israel is an imperfect society (like any other), but it has extraordinary
social, scientific and scholastic
achievements. Despite living under endless threats, it is far closer to
the liberal ideal of a free society than
any other in the Middle East. But it gets scant credit.
Europe prides itself on its tolerance of gay rights, free speech and feminism.
These are all integral to
Israeli society also, but Israel gets scant credit for that. Radical
Muslims, on the other hand, stone women,
hang homosexuals and kill to deny free speech. Do Europeans protest
that? Not many, not often.
Israel is held to a far higher standard than any other nation. Few people seem
to care much about North
Korean atrocities, at home and abroad, let alone its terrifying nuclear
defiance of the world. No one marches
or calls emergency meetings of the UN and the EU to protest the vicious
Muslim brutality against other Muslims
that takes place every day throughout the Islamic world – and beyond.
No one demonstrates on behalf of
Christians murdered in the Middle East, their churches burned. Such
horrors are waved away. Only Israel
merits such constant abuse.
The Muslim world and the Western Left are in an unholy alliance; they do not
want to improve the
Jewish state, they want to remove it. Israel has come to expect double
standards from Europe and
assault from the UN.
Much more serious is the loss of support from the Obama administration.
In his attempts to reach out to the Islamic world, Barack Obama has abandoned
the US tradition
of whole-hearted support for one of its principal allies.
He has showed himself far more tolerant of (or unconcerned by) abuses of
power in the Muslim world than
by mistakes of Israel.
Most recently, Obama backed a Nuclear Nonproliferation Treaty conference
statement that singled out Israel
in calling for a nuclear-free Middle East. No other president has ever done
that, and Israelis are understandably concerned. What Obama does not seem to
understand is that his lack of support for Israel not only saps Israel, it
emboldens its enemies.
The Middle East and the world are now a much more dangerous place as “the
sons [and daughters]
of apes and pigs” are delegitimized once again. On their way back to
Auschwitz, if their enemies succeed.
William Shawcross is a British writer and
journalist. In 2003 he wrote Allies –
Why the West had to remove Saddam. He is
now working on a book about the implications of the trial of
Khalid Sheikh Mohammed to be published by
Public Affairs Press, NYC.