* Denotes Washington PAC support in current or last election cycle
Arizona
*Jon Kyl (R) Elected
1994. 2000 Winning Percentage 79%
A staunch,
consistent, and increasingly valuable supporter.
The
conservative Kyl is facing a strong, largely self-funded, challenge
from former Arizona Dem Party Chair Jim Pederson.
Last quarter, Pederson, a shopping mall developer, donated $1.7M to his
campaign ($3.7M so far) and outspent Kyl by $1.2M.
Pederson has halved Kyl’s early poll leads and he will have popular
Dem. Gov. Jane Napolitano at the top of the Dem ticket. However, he still trailed Kyl 52% to 40% in a July poll, and
the veteran campaigner Kyl is well-positioned for the stretch run.
He has a $7.1M to $1.7M cash advantage, full support from his popular
AZ Senate colleague, John McCain, and Kyl’s tough views on illegal
immigration -- half of all illegals come through Arizona -- are well-received
in this Red state. This race will
be contested to the end, but it’s difficult to see how Kyl loses.
California
*Dianne Feinstein (D) Elected
1992. 2000 Winning Percentage 56%
Appropriations
(Defense), Intelligence.
A supportive
record, but some statements have been a cause for concern.
A
serious challenge to the popular, moderate Feinstein
was an unaffordable luxury for the GOP this year. Going bargain basement
instead, the GOP nominee is 74 year-old, ultra-conservative former state
Senator Richard Mountjoy. A no-exception abortion opponent, Mountjoy has only
$20K on hand while Feinstein has $8M and he trails in polls by a 2 to 1
margin. Game over.
Connecticut
*Joe Lieberman
(D) Elected 1988. 2000 Winning Percentage 63%
Armed
Services.
One of our most respected and
important friends in the Senate.
A
no-brainer Lieberman re-election
has transformed into a seminal political event that is threatening to rupture
the Democratic Party. Left-wing blogger driven outrage over Lieberman’s
mainstream stance on Iraq has now mushroomed into a situation where previously
unknown Greenwich millionaire Ned Lamont, who has self-funded $2.5M, is
favored to beat the former Dem. VP nominee in the August 8 primary. Lieberman
is going all out to win the primary, but is set to make an Independent run.
Adding more drama, the sole Republican who filed to run, ex-state Rep.
Alan Schlesinger, could be exiting due to gambling issues (which would give
the GOP the opportunity to appoint a stronger three-way race contender). In a
three-way race there will be so many interesting factors at play --how will
Lieberman be treated by Dems, how much will Lamont self-fund, who might the CT
GOP appoint to run. Lieberman
currently leads in three-way match-ups but Lamont is gaining.
This race is huge, stay tuned.
DElaware
*Thomas Carper
(D) Elected 2000. 2000 Winning Percentage 55%
A usually
dependable supporter.
Carper, a former Gov, Rep, and state Treasurer, is 11-0 in statewide
elections and will be 12-0. The
GOP endorsed and expected nominee is conservative law professor/ex-Bush 41
immigration official, Jan Ting. The son of Chinese immigrants, Ting is running on a get-tough
immigration platform but getting no traction nor money. The popular
well-funded Carper is incredibly safe.
Florida
*Bill Nelson
(D) Elected 2000. 2000 Winning Percentage 51%
Foreign
Relations, Armed Services.
An unblemished
record of support in his first term.
Once,
the GOP considered Nelson’s seat a
real takeover opportunity, now the GOP is just trying to avoid an embarrassing
loss in November. From the outset,
the GOP feared that Rep. Katherine Harris (good record) while popular with partisans, was too
polarizing and unpolished to beat Nelson. But
even as she was battered by scandals and campaign turmoil no serious alternative
could be convinced to run. Now,
after emergency surgery, another mass campaign staff walk-out, and the
possibility of a DOJ probe into her relationship with a lobbyist, even she did
drop out, the only other GOP candidates in the race are little known political
neophytes. They are LeRoy Collins
Jr., (son of ex-Gov/retired Admiral), Will McBride (attorney) and Pete Monroe
(developer). Harris still is the
clear primary favorite, but in general election match-ups, Nelson absolutely
demolishes her. In two June polls
Nelson led Harris 61% to 26% and 59% to 26%. He also holds a $12.6M to $2.6M
cash advantage. In a match-up with
Collins, Nelson led 65% to 13%. Not
much sunshine for the GOP in the Sunshine State this November.
Hawaii
Daniel Akaka
(D) Elected 1990. 2000 Winning Percentage 72%
Armed
Services.
Not involved in our
issues, but has an acceptable record.
While
not as bad as Joe Lieberman, Akaka is also facing a serious primary
challenge. In a surprise move,
moderate two-term Dem Rep. Ed Case (good record) decided to run on the basis
that Hawaii, with two 81 year-old Senators, needs to start transitioning to the
future now. Case believes Akaka, who Time magazine named one of the five worst
Senators and pales in comparison to his Senate partner Daniel Inouye, is the
octogenarian who should go. The Dem
leadership strongly disagrees and is solidly behind Akaka, and last quarter
Akaka outraised Case $785K to 250K. However,
Case and his new blood argument both have appeal, and in a July poll Akaka was only up 51% to 40%. With a late
primary and the calls for a candidate debate growing (Akaka has refused so far)
Case has a legitimate shot. For the
GOP, 72 year-old ex-Navy captain/motivational speaker Jerry Coffee (a POW in
Vietnam for seven years) is the likely nominee, but the GOP has no shot.
If Akaka plays it close to the vest, he will be back next year.
Indiana
Dick Lugar (R)
Elected 1976. 2000 Winning Percentage 66%
Foreign
Relations (Chairman).
In a key position,
but not very helpful on our issues.
Lugar, a fifth generation Hoosier, is already the longest serving
Senator in Indiana history and so popular that the Democrats are not even
fielding a candidate. A Libertarian is his only opposition. It doesn’t get much safer.
Maine
*Olympia Snowe (R)
Elected 1994. 2000 Winning Percentage 69%
An almost
unblemished record of support.
While
Maine voters vehemently disapprove of Pres. Bush, they feel the exact opposite
about independent-minded moderate Snowe,
as well as her GOP Senate colleague Susan Collins. This Fall, Snowe faces Dem
Jean Hay Bright (’96 candidate/organic farmer) who has $120 on hand.
In a June poll Snowe led 66% to 26% and victory is assured.
Maryland
--OPEN
*Paul Sarbanes (D)
Elected 1976. 2000 Winning Percentage 63%
Foreign
Relations.
A thoughtful and
consistent supporter over the years.
While Maryland is very Democratic (2 to 1 registration advantage), the road to retaining Sarbane’s seat could be a rough one. The GOP has a superb candidate in African-American Lt. Governor Michael Steele. Steele is a good campaigner, has more money ($3M on hand) than the top Dems, and appeals to traditionally Dem African American voters. Meanwhile, the Dems are embroiled in a closely contested primary with racial undertones between ten-term Rep. Ben Cardin (fine record) and ex-Rep/NAACP head Kwesi Mfume. The mild-mannered Cardin is the establishment choice who polls better against Steele and is way ahead in money ($2.3M on hand versus $171K). However, in recent months the charismatic Mfume has made strong gains and pulled virtually even in primary polls. A big late blitz should put Cardin over the top, but a wild card is candidate Josh Rales, a wealthy businessman who despite having little chance has already dumped $1.3M into his run and hurts Cardin. If Cardin wins the late Sept. primary, Mfume must get on board or African-American voters could sit it out or vote for Steele. However, it will be made clear in the general by Dems that the conservative Steele is no moderate. In a July poll, Cardin beat Steele 47% to 36% and Mfume beat Steele 42% to 40%. Steele has a shot, especially against Mfume, but he will need everything to break his way, which is not likely. The PAC is supporting Cardin based on his House record.
Massachusetts
*Edward Kennedy (D)
Elected 1962. 2000 Winning Percentage 73%
Armed
Services.
A veteran supporter
over the years on specific issues.
The
liberal lion Kennedy will easily win
an eighth full term, and with $8.7M on hand and in good health, he is
well-positioned to go for the Senate service record with a ninth term six years
from now in 2012. The Massachusetts legend faces minor GOP opposition in the
person of 44 year-old ex-campaign volunteer/foreign language school director Ken
Chase (who has the state GOP endorsement) and 42 year-old
ex-Selectman/businessman Kevin Scott.
*Debbie Stabenow (D)
Elected 2000. 2000 Winning Percentage 49%
A fine record of
support and assuming a leadership role.
Although
all of Stabenow’s numbers (approval, re-elect, and poll results) are in
the 40’s and low 50’s indicating vulnerability,
upon closer examination, she is looking good. In August, the GOP will choose
between Oakland County Sheriff Mike Bouchard and African American ex-Detroit
councilman/Reverend Keith Butler who are engaged in a hotly contested resource
draining primary. Bouchard is the
favorite, but his win could alienate Butler supporters in the general.
Regardless, in a July poll, both GOP candidates trailed Stabenow badly.
Stabenow topped Bouchard 50% to 29%, and Butler 52% to 25%. Also, in May
the liberal Stabenow was one of just four Dems to vote against the “amnesty
granting” Senate immigration bill, a smart move in a state with high
unemployment. Most importantly,
Stabenow has $7M on hand while the
GOP candidates each have around $1M.
Minnesota --
OPEN
Mark Dayton (D)
Elected 2000. 2000 Winning Percentage 49%
Armed
Services.
A fine record of
support.
The
open seat race to replace Dayton
is one of two serious GOP pick-up opportunities.
GOP Rep. Mark Kennedy (fine record) has been running hard since before
Dayton unexpectedly bowed out and is proving to be a very strong contender. On
the Dem side, the field has finally been cleared for Hennepin County Attorney
Amy Klobuchar, and she has maintained a slight lead over Kennedy in the polls.
While a (hotly disputed) July poll gave Klobuchar a 50% to 31% lead, one two
weeks earlier had her up only 47% to 44% more in line with previous polls. With Pres. Bush’s direct support Kennedy has lead Klobuchar
in funding ($4M to $3.5M) but the unpopularity of both Bush and the Iraq war in
Minnesota could be fatal to Kennedy, and he is trying to distinguish himself
from the President (voting support for Bush down from 97% to 87%).
Despite the race being close, it really has not heated up yet (Klobuchar
just started TV ads) but it will very soon.
Klobuchar will have all the resources she needs, and Kennedy should stay
very close, but it looks like it will take a serious slip-up by Klobuchar for
the Dems not to retain this Blue State seat.
Mississippi
*Trent Lott (R)
Elected 1988. 2000 Winning Percentage 66%
Intelligence.
A veteran
supporter.
Lott went from talking about retirement after his house was wiped
out by Katrina to now talking about getting back into the GOP Senate leadership
next Congress. One thing is
certain, he will be back, as the lightly regarded Dem. nominee, African American
state Rep./abstinence educator Erik Fleming has no chance of winning.
Missouri
*James Talent (R) Elected
2002. 2002 Winning Percentage 50%
Armed
Services
A
perfect record of support in his first term.
Talent
is locked in perhaps the closest Senate race of the
cycle against Dem state Auditor Claire McCaskill. Since last Fall, each has lead by a few points in the polls,
and a mid-July poll had them even at 42%. Missouri
has been trending GOP since 2000 and McCaskill lost a close Governor’s race in
2004, but the political atmosphere this year is favorable to Democrats and
McCaskill. First, President Bush’s 36% approval rating is among the lowest of
the 2004 states he won. Second, Talent opposes a high-profile heavily funded
stem cell ballot initiative that is favored by over 60% of Missourians (as well
as a minimum wage increase initiative favored by 66%). Both initiatives could
boost Dem turnout. McCaskill lost
in ’04 due to a poor performance in rural areas and she is now focusing on
these areas. Nonetheless, Talent is
a smart campaigner and strong in rural areas, and most significantly, he is well
ahead of McCaskill in cash $7.2M to $2.8M. McCaskill could self-fund (she
dropped $1.4M in ’04) but Talent will not be outspent.
This could be the bellwether race of the cycle and it will attract
increasing national attention.
Montana
*Conrad Burns (R) Elected
1994. 2000 Winning Percentage 51%
Appropriations
(Defense)
An
overall supportive record.
Even
though Montana’s political scene is an interesting mix of Red and Blue, at the
start of the cycle, only popular Democrat Governor Brian Schweitzer could have
had a shot at toppling two-termer Burns.
Now though, after revelations of Burns prominent role in the Jack
Abramoff scandal, he is fighting for his political life. Burns has the worst
approval ratings of any Senator and despite spending $2M last quarter (a record
for Montana), he trails the Dem nominee, state Sen. Pres. John Tester in all
polls (50% to 43% in a July poll). The
previously obscure Tester is rough-edged, clean-cut, plain-speaking organic
farmer who crushed a better funded more polished (yet also ethically challenged)
candidate in the primary. Tester is
proving an attractive alternative and a formidable challenger. Burns will have (more) money to tout his considerable work on
behalf of Montana and hit Tester on his relatively liberal social views, but
Tester matched Burns in fundraising last quarter, and with strong national
support, Tester should have the resources to counter Burns attacks.
If Tester can avoid being tied to left and getting caught in any sort of
scandal, it’s hard to see how Burns can turn things around.
This is a great pick up opportunity for the Dems.
Nebraska
Ben Nelson (D)
Elected 2000. 2000 Winning Percentage 51%
Armed
Services.
Supportive during
his freshman term.
Nelson
is defending his seat in one of Reddest
states in the Union. Registered
Republicans (580K) outnumber Democrats (370K) and Independents (185K) combined,
and Bush won by 33 points in 2004. In addition, the GOP nominee, 41 year-old
former Ameritrade executive Pete Ricketts, can self-fund.
However, in a mid-July poll Nelson led Ricketts 57% to 31%, and while the
race will tighten, Nelson is looking very strong for several reasons. First,
Cornhuskers tend to be populist and independent and not straight ticket voters.
Nelson appeals to such voters and he has 79% approval rating while Bush
is at 45%. Second, Nelson has been
endorsed by many traditionally GOP interest and business groups.
Third, while the affable Ricketts is a good candidate, he is a political
neophyte and his GOP primary victory was due largely to $5M in self-funding.
Fourth, Ricketts is very close to triggering the millionaire’s amendment which
increases contribution limits for Nelson (with $2M on hand) and in the past,
candidates who have triggered the amendment in the general have never won. While
the national GOP and fellow Nebraska Senator Chuck Hagel (no friend of Nelson
whom he beat in 1996) are stressing that a Nelson win could swing the Senate to
the Dems, its doubtful that such a partisan rationale will prevail.
Nevada
*JOHN ENSIGN (R) Elected 2000. 2000 Winning Percentage 55%
Armed
Services.
An increasingly
active and firm friend.
In
November, Ensign will face ex-Pres. Jimmy Carter’s 58 year-old son Jack
Carter. Aside from the famous name,
Carter does not make a compelling candidate. An investment consultant who has
lived in the state less than four years, Carter has never held public office and
his Navy service was marred by a dismissal for drug use. While Bush’s approval rating in Nevada is lower than any
other state he won in 2004, Ensign is in good shape. In a May poll, Ensign led
52% to 32% and leads $3.3M to $420K in cash.
There is little hope Carter can pull off an upset.
New Jersey
--OPEN
JON CORZINE (D) Elected 2000.
2000 Winning Percentage 51%
Intelligence.
An excellent record
in his one term.
Former
Rep. now Senator Bob Menendez (very good record) is filling out Corzine’s
term and locked in tight battle with GOP state Senator Thomas Kean Jr. to win a
full term in November. The 37
year-old Kean, the son of popular eponymous Governor, is a pro-choice moderate
with a clean record who is trying to cast the veteran Menendez as an
ethically-challenged machine politician. While
Kean does not have baggage like Menendez, he also does not have Menendez’s
campaign savvy, experience and fundraising skills. Kean’s campaign has already
made some missteps, and last quarter Menendez out raised Kean $2.6M ($7.4M on
hand) to $1.1M ($2.3M on hand), a disappointing showing for Kean in a very
expensive state. Kean is also being
hurt by the unpopularity of Bush and current Iraq policy but Menendez could be
hurt by Governor Corzine’s unpopular budget and tax moves. The two have traded leads in polls with Menendez on top in
the two latest polls and gaining momentum.
However, almost all polls have been within the margin of error, and there
is a fair amount of undecided and Independent voters.
This race will get very intense and negative. Neither candidate is that
well-known statewide and Menendez’s resource advantage could be key.
This race is a GOP pick-up opportunity but no GOP Senator has been
elected in the Garden State since 1972 and Kean has to step it up.
The PAC is supporting Menendez based on his House record.
JEFF BINGAMAN (D) Elected 1982. 2000 Winning Percentage 62%
A significant fall-off of support
in recent years.
In
the beginning, Bingaman was a top GOP
target (Bush won NM in ’04) but now he is absolutely safe.
The GOP nominee is urologist Allen McCulloch, a political neophyte with
only $3K compared to Bingaman’s $1.8M.
NEW YORK
HILLARY CLINTON (D) Elected 2000. 2000 Winning Percentage 55%
Armed
Services.
An excellent
record, as expected for a New York Senator.
While
Clinton’s 2008 Presidential
momentum has slowed, this race has had nothing to do with it. As if the
embarrassing cut and run by the hand-picked GOP candidate, Westchester D.A.
Jeanine Pirro, was not bad enough, Republicans now are experiencing a very
divisive primary between two political lightweights.
In the right corner is conservative ex-Yonkers Mayor John Spencer an
ethically challenged, yet wily bomb-thrower. In the left corner is ex-Pentagon
spokesperson Kathleen Troia McFarland a moderate pro-choice political newcomer
who has national appeal but no campaign and elected office experience.
Regardless of who is chosen by the GOP in September (Spencer leads in primary
polls but undecided is at almost 50%) Clinton beat both Spencer and McFarland by
around 30 points each in a July poll. The
one thing that Clinton, with $22M in the bank and counting, does not have to
worry about these days is her Senate re-election.
NORTH DAKOTA
*KENT CONRAD (D) Elected 1986. 2000 Winning Percentage 61%
A consistently supportive record.
North
Dakota is a very red state and national GOP was chagrined that Conrad
was given a pass by Gov. John Hoeven and other lesser but still strong GOP
possibilities. Perhaps it was because the hard-working moderate Conrad, a fifth
generation North Dakotan, is an excellent campaigner with $3.5M on hand and an
approval rating of 75%. His GOP
opponent this Fall will be 39 year-old town councilman Dwight Grotberg.
Grotberg has a classic Midwestern profile (farmer with seven kids) but
also no experience, no money and no chance.
OHIO
*MIKE DeWINE (R) Elected 1994. 2000 Winning Percentage 61%
Intelligence.
An excellent record
of support.
DeWine
is a thoughtful “Gang of 14” moderate Republican who has cross-party appeal.
However, he is in serious trouble as Democrats are taking advantage of
GOP malaise in Ohio caused by the scandals of his fellow Buckeye Republicans
Gov. Bob Taft and Rep. Bob Ney and dissatisfaction with President Bush. The
Democrats also have an experienced, well-funded nominee in Rep. Sherrod Brown
(fair record). Brown is a strong
candidate and campaigner but he also has a very liberal voting record that will
not play well in many areas of this Red-trending state. DeWine, with a $6.6M to
$3.8M cash advantage, will try to keep the race about issues such as national
security and the candidates positions and avoid getting swept up in an anti-GOP
tide. He must also shore up the conservative base which he has angered in the
past. The two have traded poll
leads in recent months and Brown should benefit from an open Governor’s race
at the top of ticket where currently the Dem nominee is well out in front of the
GOP nominee. This race is heating up considerably and expect record spending and
lots of national attention. Dems are definitely thinking pick-up but so far this
race does not appear to be a top-tier takeover opportunity like Pennsylvania,
Montana and Rhode Island.
PENNSYLVANIA
*RICK SANTORUM (R) Elected 1994, 2000 Winning Percentage 53%
An increasingly
important supporter with an almost perfect record of support.
Since day one, Santorum has been public enemy number one for the Dems. In a state where Dems outnumber Republicans and Kerry won, defeating one of the most outspoken Senate conservatives has been a mission. With the chance of retaking the Senate, Dems are so on mission that even when the expected Dem nominee, state Treasurer Bob Casey, a pro-lifer to begin with came out in support of Alito, pro-choice groups just shook it off. Casey is the son of a popular former Governor and has won statewide before and Dems seemed to have made a good choice. He has led Santorum consistently in the polls by 10 points or more, and was up in a June poll 52% to 37%. While Santorum’s poll numbers are the worse for any incumbent this cycle, his fundraising numbers are among the best ($3.6M last quarter and $9.5M on hand). Casey though is not far behind $2.7M/$5.2M, Santorum has the resources and tenacity for an all out assault in the final months and his moderate fellow Pennsylvania Senator Arlen Specter is also being of help. This race will break all state spending records and should get (even more) negative. So far the Casey coalition is holding and this seat is looking like a Democratic takeover.
RHODE ISLAND
LINCOLN CHAFEE (R) Elected 2000. 2000 Winning Percentage 57%
Foreign
Relations (Chair Middle East Subcommittee).
A very
disappointing record in a key position.
While
the independent-minded Chafee opposed
the war in Iraq and Justice Alito, and did not vote for the President in 2004,
the national GOP is backing him to the hilt. In a state where Kerry won by 21 points and Bush has a nation
leading 75% disapproval rating its clear he is their only hope to retain the
seat. Not all GOP’ers are willing
to hold their nose though, and conservative Cranston Mayor Steve Laffey is
waging a well-funded well-organized Club for Growth supported challenge that has
Chafee reaching out to Dems and Indys for primary support.
While this may help for the primary, in the general election against the
Dem nominee ex-AG/’02 Gov nominee Sheldon Whitehouse Chafee is in trouble. In
June, Whitehouse erased earlier Chafee poll leads and in a July poll he
led 46% to 41%. Chafee, like
his late Senator father, has cross-over appeal, but in a year in which Dems have
a chance to take control of the Senate, it could be very hard to get past the
(R) after his name. Whitehouse is also running a good campaign and led Chafee in
fundraising last quarter $1M to 720K and cash on hand $1.8M to $1M.
There is a very good chance that Chafee, a former horse shoer, could be
heading back to the stable next year. The
PAC supported Laffey.
TENNESSEE -- OPEN
BILL FRIST (R) Elected 1994. 2000 Winning Percentage 66%
Fine voting record
but supported few initiatives.
In
the race to fill Frist’s
open seat, the August 3rd primary cannot come soon enough for the
GOP. A negative resource draining three way contest between former Chattanooga
Mayor/’94 candidate Bob Corker, former Rep/’02 candidate Ed Bryant, and
former Rep./’02 Gov nominee Van Hilleary is providing ammunition to the
Democrats. Corker is being painted as a faux conservative, but his superior
fundraising ($6.6M to $2M each for Bryant and Hillerary) seems to be the
difference. Corker led by double digits in two July primary polls but with a
fair amount of undecided voters
(around 30%) he recently self-funded $1.7M for a final push. Meanwhile, Dem.
Rep. Harold Ford Jr. (good record) is canvassing the state, raising money ($1.8M
last quarter) and effectively using national issue ads to deflect the
“liberal” label. The moderate
Corker with his big checkbook poses the most trouble for Ford.
In a July poll Corker beat Ford 42% to 37%, while Ford was tied with
Bryant and Hillerary. Whomever the
GOP nominee, the party has won nine straight open Southern Senate seats and is
the slight favorite (especially with Corker).
However, given the national scene this year and Ford’s determination
and fundraising prowess, this seat could be
the magical sixth takeover for the Democrats.
The PAC is supporting Ford based on his House record.
TEXAS
KAY BAILEY HUTCHISON (R) Elected 1993. 2000 Winning Percentage 66%
Appropriations
(Defense).
Consistently
supportive.
Hutchison is facing a spirited challenge from Dem nominee Barbara
Ann Radnofsky a 50 year-old Houston attorney/mediator and political first-timer.
However, Radnofsky’s spunk and her $340K on hand is no match for Hutchison’s
62% approval rating and $9.3M on hand. In a July poll Hutchison, with virtually
no campaigning, was up 53% to 34%, and with all eyes focused on the race for
Governor and Tom Delay’s seat this race will be a yawner.
*ORRIN HATCH (R) Elected 1976. 2000 Winning Percentage 66%
Intelligence
An overall fine
record of support.
The
musically inclined Hatch wrote over
300 songs the last decade and in 2005 earned $40K in royalties. This Fall he can
continue to pen lyrics with little opposition coming from Democrat Pete Ashdown.
A 39 year-old Internet executive with no political experience, Ashdown is
allegedly pioneering ways to use the Internet to campaign, but with little
success. In a June poll Hatch was
up 67% to 23% and has a huge cash advantage and will be back.
VERMONT--OPEN
JIM JEFFORDS (I) Elected 1988. 2000 Winning Percentage 66%
A comparatively
poor record –the “Vermont syndrome”?
The
race to succeed Jeffords
between Independent eight-term Rep. Bernie Sanders (poor record) and expected
GOP nominee Richard Tarrant has been very active and already broken state
spending records. Tarrant, a
medical software company founder has self-funded $4.4M forcing Sanders to hit
the phones ($1M last quarter). Also
unprecedented, Sanders agreed to be
on the Dem primary ballot so after he wins the primary, he can decline that
nomination, and then just Independent Sanders and Republican Tarrant will be on
the general election ballot. Nonetheless, it is highly doubtful that Vermonters
can be swayed by Tarrant’s money, and in a June poll
Sanders beat Tarrant 67% to
29%. It a lock that Congress’
only avowedly socialist member will take a Senate seat.
VIRGINIA
*GEORGE ALLEN (R) Elected 2000. 2000 Winning Percentage 52%
Foreign
Relations.
A perfect record of
support in his freshmen term.
Allen will need to scale back his 2008 presidential plans, as all
hands on deck could be needed to repel a strong challenge from his Dem opponent
ex-Reagan Navy Secretary James Webb. Webb,
a decorated Vietnam vet who switched parties a few years ago partly because of
Iraq, showed considerable potential in winning the Dem primary and is an
attractive candidate. The combat
boot wearing Webb is making Allen’s support for permanent American bases in
Iraq (and his lack of military service) plus Allen’s opposition to stem cell
research central campaign themes. Allen
is going after Webb’s Hollywood support and his unfamiliarity with local
issues affecting Virginians. Money
will be key and after a resource draining primary Webb had only $425K on hand
compared to Allen’s $6.6M. While
Allen would like to conserve for 2008, he spent $2.4M last quarter and will
spend what it takes to win. His approval ratings are also only in the low
50’s. A June Webb poll had Allen
up 46% to 39% while an Indy poll had it at 51% to 41% and another 56% to 39%.
Webb can expect considerable national support and the election of Dem.
Gov. Tim Kaine in ’04 (who has a 67% approval rating) showed that Dems can do
well in ex-urban counties. This
race will garner national attention and could be competitive.
WASHINGTON
MARIA CANTWELL (D) Elected 2000. 2000 Winning Percentage 49%
Not particularly involved in our
issues, but a fine record. (She
does not accept PAC contributions).
The
47 year-old freshman Cantwell who defeated incumbent Slade Gorton by less than 2500 votes
in 2000 is facing an increasingly difficult race in her bid for a second term.
The Republican candidate Mike McGavick, a 48 year-old former insurance company
executive who used to work for Gorton, is proving to be a star recruit, and is
running a well-funded ($5M spent so far) effective campaign.
A lot of Cantwell’s trouble though is coming from her left due to her
support for the Iraq war. In July, she voted for a Senate resolution setting a date to
start troop withdrawal and was able to convince one anti-war Dem candidate to
drop out of the race and join her staff (at a nice salary), but the fear is
still that some Dems (also angry that she did not support an Alito filibuster)
will simply not vote or vote for anti-war Independent Aaron Dixon in November.
McGavick meanwhile has maximum support from his party including top GOP
Senators, and in two June polls Cantwell’s once double digit lead shrunk to
47% to 43% and 44% to 40%. Nonetheless,
while recent Gubernatorial, Presidential and Senate races in the Evergreen State
have been closely decided, Republicans have not won one since 1994, and Bush’s
35% approval rating will not help. Cantwell
also has a sizable $6.4M to $1M cash advantage. McGavick, can self-fund and this race could be very close and
may come down to whether ultra-liberal Dems help elect a Republican.
WEST VIRGINIA
ROBERT BYRD (D) Elected 1958. 2000 Winning Percentage 78%
Appropriations
(Defense), Armed Services.
Definitely the
worst record on our issues in the
U.S. Senate.
The
88 year-old Byrd, who in June became the longest serving Senator in
history, will face ’84 Sen./’88 Gov candidate John Raese in November. Raese,
an industrialist, can self-fund ($1.4M so far), and he is mounting an aggressive
campaign. However, West Virginians
have little reason to abandon Byrd, a Mountain State legend and the “King of Pork.” Byrd led Raese 59% to 30% in a June poll
and his approval ratings are near 70%. Only
a major slip-up by Byrd could make this race competitive.
WISCONSIN
HERB KOHL (D) Elected 1988. 2000 Winning Percentage 62%
A fine record with
just a few exceptions.
Kohl has an undistinguished Senate record and several Wisconsin
Republicans (notably ex-Gov Tommy Thompson) could have given Kohl a run for his
considerable money. Instead, with
the filing deadline passed, Kohl has a cakewalk. His GOP opponent will be ’02
Sec. of State nominee/’04 candidate/attorney Robert Lorge. Kohl beat Lorge 60%
to 27% in a July poll and Kohl, a
retail mogul who almost 100% self-funds ($4.8M so far) will be able to save some
money this year.
WYOMING
CRAIG THOMAS (R) Elected 1994. 2000 Winning Percentage 74%
Usually supportive,
but not particularly involved.
Thomas will square off against Dem. Dale Groutage. If this was a
science meet, Groutage, with a B.S. Masters, and PH.D in science and 34 years as
a military research scientist would be the prohibitive favorite. However, it’s
a political election, and Thomas, with a 30 point lead in a July poll and a $1M
to $8K advantage will easily win.